A Fantasy Author's Adventures in Fiction & Life

Tag: Nonbinary

My epic SciFi-Fantasy; Walking the Knife’s Edge and its main character Rarkin were rare things for me as a writer; a fully developed character who struts onto the page, and a story that near writes itself. That’s because Rarkin was born of the story of the formative years of my life, a story interrupted by loss and grief. Rarkin’s tendency to keep feelings in and people out grew from my own response to grief. And many lessons he learns are lessons I learnt too. These are the stories behind his story.

Content warnings: grief, depression, references to physical child abuse and neglect -not of me.

School on ‘The Wrong Side of Town’

Rarkin is resident of Brock Heights, ‘the wrong side of town.’ Its a poor, rundown neighbourhood. I grew up in a town divided by a set of train tracks, with a ‘wrong side’ of the tracks. I went to school on the’ wrong side’, with hundreds of other students.

My school had an oval which slopped steeply downwards, with grass long enough for kids to hide in. The yard duty teacher could only see the out of bounds slope when they stood on the back of the oval -so most of the time it was out of their sight. All sorts misadventures happened. Yes, I was in a few. I also enjoyed playing kiss chasey, because it was the best game for making use of out of bounds areas.

‘Law of the Jungle’

But even in areas of school grounds supposedly supervised by yard duty teachers, there were too few teachers, too many students, and the yard duty teacher’s line of sight was often blocked. I assume that’s why so many kids got away with punching other kids for pretty much no reason. Or being verbally abusive.

I saw a lot of angry boys in those days. Sometimes, if you bumped into them, they would flinch, as if bruises or welts lay under their school uniforms. Those weren’t from fighting. I realised, at a very young age, that they came from abusive fathers or stepfathers.

You had two choices in that playground; be scared, or be brave, aggressive and hit back harder. Unlike Rarkin, it wasn’t standing up to an abusive parent that made me tough; it was standing up to bullies at school. Especially when they hit smaller kids. That really pissed me off.

Holding It All In

When you’re a female presenting child who hits bullies back, in the nineties, its a bit of an issue. Boys weren’t supposed to hit girls. But I learnt to punch as hard as a boy. And I learnt how to death glare from the best of them. But I didn’t look like a boy. So the idea they might need to hit me did not appeal to some of them.

I suspect it made things more comfortable for a few tough boys when I was adopted by a group of tough boys. Was it my reputation for hitting bullies back harder, or fear that if bullies hit small kids in front of me, I hit the bullies, then the bullies hit me; that my new male friends would be after the bullies blood? I’m not sure, but either way I only recall getting into one punch up after that. And it was in that friendship group that I came to learn Rarkin’s approach to feelings.

Officially, the only emotion tough boys at that school displayed freely was anger. And perhaps frustration, but that normally boiled over into anger. Tears weren’t a done thing. Tough boys didn’t cry. Except on rare occasions, when they did.

I didn’t understand it at the time, but now, I think they only showed anger and expressed themselves through violence aggression, because they didn’t know any other way. Because that’s the only role modelling they ever had at home. Because they feared their own anger, and didn’t want to hurt people, so they held it in. Until it boiled over and out. (Yes, is suspect their abusive fathers were the same.)

That’s where Rarkin’s story begins. Betrayed, via abuse, over and over by someone whose supposed to love and protect him, who frequently abuses him instead. Heart broken. Angry. On the brink of boiling over.

Loss of Friends

In Rarkin’s case, its lack of trust that prompts him to keep everyone at arm’s length. He’s used to being seen as a thug because he looks the wrong way, and lives in the wrong place. But my experience was different. It was the 90’s. There was ‘no such thing as nonbinary.’ But having proven I could be as brave as a boy, hit as hard a boy, given, effectively given boy status, I had both a boy friendship group and a girl one. As many male and female friends as I wanted. I was accepted on both sides of the gender divide. I felt whole, and my life was balanced.

But the way I remember it, some of my friends were expelled. And they ran away. I never saw them again. Two friendship groups became one. I lost the group Rarkin values so much. The group that’s been through shit. The group where you could speak bluntly about life, and you didn’t upset people, or make them uncomfortable. You called shit what it was, you connected and you understood each other. I lost the only friends I have ever felt truly and completely understood me. The ones I told all my secrets too.

Loss of Self & Gender Challenges

I lost people I trusted. Being understood. Truly belonging. And then a new school opened up, on the ‘right side of town.’ In hindsight, the reason I chose to change schools wasn’t just because my girl friendship group was moving. It was because I feared for my mental health if I stayed. I felt my male friends’ absence acutely, and I was too aware of how the tough boys were suffering. Of neglect, abuse, and cops and foster homes only kicking in when one boy was severely beaten. Otherwise; grown ups seemed to do fuck all about child abuse. Teachers didn’t seem to realise it was happening. I couldn’t see the point of the cops, as they seemed to do nothing to protect vulnerable kids from abusive or neglectful parents.

So I changed schools and lost the tough crowd altogether. I lost my people and my boy status. And I lost a giant chunk of who I was and my sense of being a whole person. Only now, on the eve of my fortieth birthday, do I truly understand why that grief effected me so profoundly. I didn’t merely lose my found family; part of me died with them.

Other Losses

But the worst part of it was there were other losses. My parents got divorced. Our cat died. My Nan, the only adult I tended to confide in, died. Pop noticed I was sad, and took to calling me every now and then and telling me jokes to cheer me up. He died too. Mum got a new partner. I think he noticed I was sad too. He would try, in small ways, like noting my love of cereal or making sure I had a say in what the family group were doing, to perhaps cheer me up. It didn’t work. But I saw that he cared. And that helped. And he died.

Then there was a PE teacher at my new school. I was rubbish at sport. Poorly co-ordinated, and I moved too fast because ADHD (utterly unknown to me then). I didn’t see the point of PE. But he encouraged me. He encouraged me so much that I didn’t just try at sport. He made me start to believe in myself. And yes, he died too.

Hating Yourself

One friendship group was left now; girls. I was perceived as a girl. I was expected to behave like a girl. In having lost my male friendship group, I lost the person I was with them. All the courage, spirit, intolerance for bullshit and feistiness, the very spirit of formative years of my life; they weren’t there anymore. It was like they’d died.

In hindsight; it was probably clinical depression. I didn’t even cry when Pop died. I lost too many people, even my childhood home, a one acre block with lots of trees to climb and a big backyard for playing imaginary games in. After all that, I couldn’t grieve everything and everyone. There was too much grief. So I sank into depression, and that catatonically numbed everything I admired and respected and perhaps even liked about myself.

I missed my old friends. Missed my old self. I struggled to see what there was left that made life worth living, because the gaping hole in my life was so big that it was hard to notice anything that still existed outside it. I struggled to see what was left of me that was of value, because I felt like only the barest, tinniest scraps of the person I had been remained.

Hating Everything Being Off Kilter

All this was made worse, because these were my final years of primary school and my first years of high school. Friendship groups had become rigidly boys or girls. Everything was out of balance with only girls as friends, and people only expected me to behave like a girl. It was like I was cut in half. And the worst time for me as a nonbinary person.

I barely had the spirit and feistiness to be my masculine self anymore. Exhaustion and world weariness meant I had nothing left to figure out how to be nonbinary. I’d never heard the word, didn’t know what it was. Had no idea how much of me was missing, or cut off, or why, or what to do about it.

So I didn’t think much of myself. But my story was of loss of friends, found family, and self. It was how an ignorant society gave me no opportunity to be my nonbinary self, and how I was too depressed to attempt it properly. Very different to Rarkin having no self esteem, because his own father frequently treated him like shit. But very similar feelings.

Isolation

Rarkin is lucky. I granted him the male friendship group I lost. He has them from the age six of six onwards. His tendency to shut everyone out is partly because he expects discrimination from everyone outside Brock Heights. But its also because he has a lot of insecurities, fears and pains as result of his upbringing, and he trusts no one outside Brock Heights with any of it.

Again, my experience differed. The female friendship group I had through my second primary school? There were fractures in it, while we were at school. I could clash horribly with one of my friends. So much so the teachers put three of us in different grades for our last two years of school, all but forcing us to make new friends. But the deathnell for those friendships was us all going to different high schools.

So it was that I rocked up at my high school, without a single friend from my primary school, with only one other kid I knew by name in my year level. Depressed, and feeling like a fragment of my former self. Yet to grieve everyone I’d lost properly.

Part of me hungered for friendship, but my emotional maturity was at least four, if not five or six years ahead of my peers. I felt like I was surrounded by five year olds. Or sheep. They were shallow, superficial, conformist. I hated everything they stood for. But mostly, I think I hated that I saw nothing of myself in my peers and couldn’t connect with them at all.

‘Safe Friendships’

That’s when, having got a mere ‘C’ grade for a rambling story with no structure in year 7, I wrote down some ideas in year 8. A daydream about a prince’s parents being abducted. Idle day dreams of myself, and my friends Fiona and Laura, and a boy who annoyed my friend Laura, called Troy, and for good measure, Troy’s friends Andrew and Michael, getting out of school and stumbling into a fantasy world.

Six kids in another world was too many, so I reduced it to four. And one got re-named. That was the origins of Linh, Fiona, Troy and Michael of Ruarnon Trilogy. The prince became the ‘different type of masculine’ they’d always been; nonbinary Heir Ruarnon. And I wrote myself the friends I wished I had, right through high school, on into my twenties, editing and publishing them in my thirties.

A fictional friendship group could be as queer and neurodivergent as I at the time had no labels to describe myself with, or known identities to associate with myself. Better; they could never and would never be taken away from me.

Keeping Everyone At Arm’s Length

But what of real friends? Lone wolf though I’d very much become, I could see that I wouldn’t be happy without friends. But I had so little in common with so many kids around me. I didn’t really feel accepted until year 9; by anyone. And I never truly fit. But I got on well with a bunch of misfits, nerds and immigrant kids. It was a blessed relief to have male friends again. My spirit was recovering, my feistiness, temper and aggression were coming back and I was starting to feel like me again.

I was aware of meeting people I quite liked and connected with, and of not telling them too much. Of not letting them in properly. Not allowing them to get too close, lest I lose people again. I’d lost too many people. I wouldn’t risk losing anyone else.

But now I realise it was more than that. There was no chance in hell I was going to risk losing so much of myself again. So I didn’t talk too much, or too personally. Hugging friends was a trend then, but I was NOT into it, and lukewarm when people enthusiastically tried to hug me, even if people I quite liked.

Meeting of Minds

That’s the other thing; like Rarkin; I’m autistic. And I’m the kind of autistic person who mostly wants to meet your mind. If we’re two spirits cut from the same cloth; I’m thrilled to meet your spirit. But rarely do I wish to touch anyone, even in an affectionate manner. Sure, I might hug family in greeting or goodbye, especially now, as with chronic illness I’m inclined to travel to see them less often. But as a teen I did not want people touching me, or to let them in. Didn’t want to chance forming the found family I’d once had, lest I lose it and myself again.

And so by a different route; Rarkin and I both tended to shut people around us out, as teens.

Knowing Your Own Worth

My spirit, the fight that made me hit back bullies, look out for younger kids, insist on hugging tough boy friends because I don’t give a fuck if they don’t cry because they ARE crying and I will hug them and I will even make them hug each other! The feisty kid who stormed into the kitchen at 1am and screamed at my parents to shut up, sit down and talk it out like adults! That was always the core of kid me. So what was there to like, without it? How could I believe in a me who was a pale shadow of my former self?

And despite my fighting spirit, I’ve always tended to doubt I can do new things. Maybe its physical things due to my lack of co-ordination (which I now swear borderline presented as dyspraxia in childhood -it was serious unco for mere unco!) Perhaps the logical, autistic part of my brain had to see me doing a thing to believe I could, because it knew I was shit at things like remembering things, didn’t posses organisational skills, got lost easily, lost possessions all the time -the usual ADHD stuff!

Reconnecting

Feeling cut off from or like chunks of myself had died; I had a lot to rediscover wasn’t dead, was still there, could be revived. And some things did change, and I reconciled who I was before, who I was while healing, and the person I was becoming, and knew I wasn’t quite the same as before. I had to learn to appreciate, like and value myself again, and prove to myself that I was still capable.

For different reasons -namely having everything he’s ever ‘done wrong’ shoved in his face by an abusive father, and prejudiced people who expect little of him, Rarkin has the same need to prove himself to himself. To convince himself of himself.

Gender; Mine’s Nonbinary

I’ve talked about the challenges of growing up as a nonbinary person in a world oblivious to the existence of my gender, with little choice but to adopt a friendship group that only meets half my friend, and gender identity needs. So you may be wondering; why is Rarkin a cis gender male?

I began writing Rarkin at I think the age of eighteen. The first draft of Sythe Series was completed during my Uni years, in which I loved writing a blunt, straight spoken character, in contrast to the waffling, blathering readings I had to do for Uni. Or my super well spoken professors who almost sounded British (I’m Aussie.) But the thing I most loved about writing Rarkin was having a space to exist as my masculine self.

I appeared to be a tall, thin, pretty blonde girl. I was smothered in positive reinforcement to adhere to binary gender norms, in the form of compliments and endless smiles when I presented in a feminine manner. And I did like dresses and pretty things. In those days, I even liked dresses on my body, as opposed to saying ‘that’s pretty and moving on’ -my default now. I lived feminine in those days, partly. I also had some more gender neutral outfits, and could be aggressive towards annoying boys at times. But my masculine self didn’t have the space it needed to exist.

Gender; Why Rarkin’s Cis Male

Rarkin was where I poured my bluntness, my impatience, aggression, my temper, my ‘masculine’ traits. He was the space in which the masculine side of me lived, the other half of the balance that childhood me found in having a masculine and feminine friendship group both. Rarkin could have blunt conversations with friends he trusted, who understood him. He could spar with them. No one pressured him, positively or negatively, to smile or be sociable. So in writing him, I could embrace all the parts of me that didn’t fit into my life in reality, and those parts could stretch out, and breathe, and feel comfortable.

This wasn’t something I fully experienced in reality until I identified as nonbinary in my thirties, and dressed and behaved a bit more ‘masculine’ since then.

Healing

Rarkin has a massive character arc, both in healing from trauma and learning to trust and let others in, and in learning to love himself and see his own worth. It spans Sythe Series books 1 and 2. I said at the start that he walked onto the page fully formed, and his story wrote itself. That’s because even as I wrote the first draft in my late teens and early twenties; I’d done A LOT of self reflection.

Unlike Rarkin; I did not see a therapist. I wrote poems to get out all the feelings that were too ugly, and raw or unpleasant for any other form of expression, mostly my grief, out and off my chest. Listened to music and wrote Ruarnon Trilogy (which deals with grief and loss), and Sythe Series. I gave myself the friends of my dreams in fiction.

But by my time at Uni, despite still having not found my queer or neurodivergent labels, or properly understood any of those identities; I was making queer and neurodivergent friends. I was finding my people, living on campus my first year of Uni. Bought a car and mum insisted that I drive her to my campus to prove that I could (it was a two hour drive -ample room for me to get lost!)

I’d written an autobiography (no I am not promising that will ever see the light of day!) as well, to help me process my past, get my feelings out, and had reflected a lot on how I was, and why, and how I’d become and was still intentionally becoming a happier, healthier person. In a way, I didn’t need to do any planning for the arc of Rarkin’s emotional and social development. Because I’d lived it. It was a good chunk of the story of the formative years of my life.

A Note on Rarkin’s Growth

Rarkin’s healing and attempts to let people in span a good chunk of book 2 of Sythe Series, as well as book 1. Everything he does internally in both of those will situate him uniquely in a struggle in the wider world of Umarinaris in books 3 and 4; at the centre of a revolution. I suspect writing such a personally significant character, and having his development and lived experience key to the central conflict in his world, may make this the most rewarding series I’ve ever written. Not least the very things that made him struggle, and his ability to overcome them, position him as just the person Sythe needs as Umarinaris’ status quo is shaken to its foundations. I can’t wait to write books 3 and 4 of this series!

You can find Rarkin’s story; Walking the Knife’s Edge, at many stores in my Sythe Series page.

Epic Scifi-Fantasy, with Crime.
Raised on the wrong side of town by an abusive father, Rarkin keeps feelings in, and people out. But in his training for Monster Containment; making friends is inevitable, keeping people at arm's length is impossible, and learning to trust others to keep him alive alive is obligatory. Especially when a crime boss goes rogue.Right: Sythe Series Book 1, Walking the Knife's Edge
Cover:  Rarkin raises a hand gun, standing beside Miona raising gloved fists, on a grassy hillside in the countryside.Bottom left: Direct from author, Bookshop.org, Kobo, Itchio, Apple, Everand, Booktopia, Hoopla, Barnes & Noble, Request at your local library.
Get blogs in your inbox and updates from Elise every second Month. Join my Fiction Frolics. Select this image to learn more.

Related Reading

If I’ve somehow not talked your ear off and you’d like to hear more from me, I’ve blogged elsewhere about when I did identify as;

Nonbinary

Asexual

Aromantic

Autistic

ADHD

For me Pride is complex. Raised in a cis, binary, heterosexual world that gave me zero role models and was oblivious to my existence means that like many, I didn’t realise my identities were queer until later in life. After three years, I still haven’t referred to queer history as ‘our history’ or the LGBTQIA+ community as ‘our community’. That seems presumptuous. And I hit these difficulties before considering what often looks to me like performative corporate allyship, companies mass producing queer products to capitalise on profits and people all saying ‘happy pride,’ while Florida’s government policies actively reshape it into a queer hellscape.

Pride Right Now

Two large rainbows arch over grassy Arthur's seat, before sunlit Edinburgh and a grey, cloudy sky in Scottland.

Pride At Work

I haven’t mentioned that its Pride Month at work. Work has been insanely busy, we’re all sick and there’s hardly a moment or the headspace to comment on something that isn’t work. I’m also the only openly queer person in my workspace and while my colleagues are kind, well meaning people, there’s a lot of ignorance. I’m not sure how much interest there is for things queer or how to proceed when I’m the only person flying the rainbow flag before all my cishet colleagues.

Pride Online

So I’m mostly seeing Pride online, packed with corporate performative allyship posts, and ‘love is love’ and ‘lets work together to make things better.’ And the cynical part of me wonders if that post is the only thing that organisation will do during Pride month (or ever), to support queer people. I’m sure some groups do more, but it almost feels like being accepting of queer people is politically correct, and socially and morally obliged, and mass displays of it at this one time of year can feel insincere.

On the flip side, so many organisations publicly displaying their acceptance of queer people does, as many recent tweets have pointed out, show the haters that hating on queer people isn’t the norm. That such hatred is unwelcome in many spaces. And while that causes initial inevitable backlash (which I’m fortunate enough to have only seen online, not irl), I share the optimism that it will ultimately help normalise being queer (especially being trans!).

Indie Author Pride Online

I was grateful when Indie Book Spotlight started #IndiePride2 and I had a means of connecting with fellow queer authors. One of the prompt questions was: what does Pride mean to you? To some on the hashtag, its a celebration of how far queer people and our status in society has come. From being gay being illegal and legally defined as a mental illness, to gay marriage being legalised in many countries, for example. But also a time to protest, and to look at what still needs to be achieved. I’d define that partly as every homophobic argument made against gay men in the 80’s/ 90’s now being argued against trans people, and the legislative assault trans people are coming under, in Florida and California in particular.

Reaching Pride, Space to Be Queer

But before discussing the present and future, I’d like to look back to how I personally and many others came to the realisation we are queer, and Pride is for us. Because things don’t just happen in a vacuum, and many of us were unable to recognise our identities for a long time, because to us our world was a vacuume.

Queerness in The 90’s

I had no idea I was queer as a child. I played with girls. I played with boys. I played with girls and boys toys. I liked pretty clothes and pragmatic clothes. And like many 90’s kids, I knew you could be gay or straight. And that was about it. It didn’t stop me from punching bullies back. ‘Girls didn’t do that’, and I ‘was a girl’ in everyone else’s eyes. But I saw the world as I saw it, I thought what I thought, felt what I felt, believed what I believed and would not tolerate shit I would not tolerate. I demanded male respect while presenting as female in a sexist era. I suppose in some ways I was ‘one of the boys’ and in others ‘one of the girls’ and nowhere did I truly fit.

Queerness in The 2000’s

‘Transexual’ was mentioned a little more then. The notion of a ‘man in a woman’s body’ and you could ‘get a sex change’. It was such early days for gender diversity. There were still such rigid expectations for women. Slut shaming was still at full throttle. But the ‘metrosexual’ was coined. Men were starting to break free of recent limitations in male gender expression, some growing their hair out, experimenting with make up, etc. And that helped me, because I realised those men were more feminine than I, and I more masculine than them. There was a little more space for me to recognise my own gender diversity.

Of course, there was still nothing like a single role model of anyone I wanted to be when I grew up. Because the gender binary was still an absolute power. But Blink 182 were rocking the charts alongside ‘metrosexual’ male artists and there seemed a little more room for queer existence than before. I even heard the terms ‘bisexual’ and ‘lesbian’. By my late teens, people were starting to say that using ‘gay’ as an insult was disrespectful to gay men and were beginning to discourage others from doing so.

It felt like millennials were starting to make and or create space to be alternative. To break away from the mainstream. Including to be queer. But so many queer labels and identities were so little, or not even understood, that for many of us, this was a time where we struggled to be what we could not see.

You Can’t Be What You Can’t See

Let me put not having labels or definitions for who I was into context. When I was 10 years old (in the 90s), I went to a family event and a male relative was there with a friend of his. My dad quietly told me, “That’s his boyfriend.” By the early 2000’s, another family member had joined the Melbourne Gay and Lesbian choir, and attending that choir’s Christmas Carols for several years became a family tradition.

I had the privilege of being raised in a family where queer family members who recognised themselves as such were welcomed, and where Pride was totally accepted. It was a very safe environment for me to ‘come out.’ But it wasn’t enough. ‘Gay’ meant loving the opposite or opposite and same sex back then. It didn’t mean not romantically loving anyone. It didn’t mean not experiencing sexual attraction. ‘Everyone’ in fiction, on tv, in books, in the movies, in real life ‘wanted’ a girlfriend/ boyfriend, and ‘wanted’ to have sex with them, sometimes on the first meeting, which I always found absurd. And ‘everyone’ everywhere ‘was a man or a woman.’

So What Am I?

Its very challenging to be proud of who you are, when you don’t even have names for the things you are. (Trust me, I’ve spent over 30 years trying to do just that ?). I respected gays, lesbians and bisexuals. I liked how they just did their thing, despite peer pressure, despite prejudice. That they went out every day defying what most people expected them to be, and were just themselves. I tried to do the same, on my own, with no role modelling what so ever, because I didn’t have labels or a clear definition of who I was, nor any examples about how to express myself as a person.

Pride as Living Space

So how can anyone be queer when you’re queer in a way that’s ‘not a thing’? Let alone how do you be proud about it? If I felt masculine, I did masculine. If I liked a guy but didn’t actually want to ask him out, or even date him, I didn’t ask him out and tried not to encourage him too much. I slowly clawed my way towards a wardrobe balancing feminine and gender neutral attire. I wrote books from female and male perspectives, alternating between them as much as I wanted.

But I didn’t gain clarity about who I was, or how to more happily be me, until I started seeing others trying to do the same. I shrugged off the many people suggesting I try online dating because ‘surely I must want a romantic and sexual partner because isn’t that what every human wants’? I moved house, country etc (surrendering to the ADHD desire for novelty and challenges, long before recognising I had ADHD ‘only boys had ADHD in the 90s’ ?). That was a convenient excuse for never bothering to date, because I never lived anywhere long. But neither I nor anyone else had terms for what I was, so they kept expecting me to want what I didn’t want.

Pride as You Can Be Who You Can See

I know many people are wary of politics on Twitter, or fear it as a hellscape, even before current management took over. But Twitter was where I found Pride. No, not the month. Pride as in people who put things in their bios like ‘asexual’ or even… they/them pronouns. I started meeting and interacting with people who were queer beyond being same or same and opposite sex attracted. I learnt from them and we learnt from each other that there are so many other queer identities. That humanity has far more ways of being than the exceptionally limited cookie cutters society had been jamming us all into since childhood, despite plenty of us never fitting.

As I said in my blog Identifying as Nonbinary, identifying my pronouns and telling them to other people was an outward way to give myself permission to be my nonbinary self. To wear feminine, masculine or gender neutral clothing. To relate to other people as just a person, even and especially when they want to relate to each other and everyone else as ‘woman’ or ‘man.’

Many in my queer generation (and earlier generations) have had to overcome the disconnect between blundering through the dark to define and express ourselves and society inventing names for us 20, 30 even 40 years later. You have this vague sense of who you are and how to be you, and then these external, ‘foreign’ labels and gender identities pop up, and it can take years for you to realise you are that thing and it is a part of you.

Pride to Save Time

Let’s fast forward to the present. Now its not just Gay & Lesbian, its LGBTQIA+. Not only can you be bisexual, you can be pansexual. You can be aromantic, or asexual or demisexual. Its trans people now, trans men and women, a gender appropriately named as a gender and not lumped in with the word ‘sexual’ even though it isn’t a sexuality. And you can be nonbinary, and gender queer and agender and SO MANY things. And with names, and definitions and books like Heart Stopper and shows like Umbrella Academy, people can see their gender and sexuality in fiction. With safe online spaces and pronouns and sexualities in bios, people can see diversity in online life.

Its no longer necessary to blunder through the dark. There are names to go with identities, and fictional and real life people to look to as examples. Its easier than ever to find your queer people, to not be alone. To have people to share experiences and challenges with. To ask questions of. To find your way on your journey of being and expressing your authentic self with.

And then there’s the bigots.

Get Back in the Closest

Yes, that’s exactly what a religious nut job recently told me, right after accusing me personally of turning western civilisation into a circus for daring to encourage, via public tweet, people to live as their queer selves. Its easy to laugh off extremists like that. And people running around saying, “the Bible says its a sin, don’t be proud to be queer” when the supposed lord and saviour of these supposed Christians said stuff like “let he who is without sin throw the first stone” and something about attending to the plank in one’s own eye before attending to the speck in one’s neighbour’s. And who, despite popular opinion in some circles that he said “hate thy neighbour” actually said “love thy neighbour as thyself.”

But Pride Month had barely began before the book What is a Woman, so packed full of attacks on trans people’s existence that I soon forgot it supposedly related to women, was released. And people are tweeting about ‘Family Pride Month,’ you know, ‘family’ as defined by bigots, in opposition to all things queer. Then there’s the ‘when do we get straight pride month?’ crowd, who are so used to everything always being about them that a whole month dedicated to someone else is apparently more than they can cope with.

A lot of the above may just be noise. But the 369 anti-trans bills currently active in the United States are not. These bills include things like denying teachers and students the right to be addressed by pronouns not matching their biological sex on their birth certificate (which would misgender me). They include limiting gender affirming care (care which spares people being trapped in a body that every time you see its reflection isn’t you, because it doesn’t match your gender, aka dysmorphia).

I’ve been very lucky with dysmorphia. My body is a mix of classic masculine and feminine traits. Only seeing myself on film do I see someone whose face or expressions aren’t right, or their voice sounds wrong. Its like watching a mockery of myself, when it is actual footage of me. I wouldn’t wish that on anyone. To wish, let alone force dysmorphia on people is to wish them mental illness and self harm. And that’s exactly what Desantis seems to be praying to God for trans people to have.

The Future

So much has been gained in recent decades. Pride Month seems to get bigger each year. And yes, it is nice to say ‘happy Pride!’ and to celebrate all the queer community is and has achieved. And queer joy can be a rare thing, so much so that I don’t feel I can enter my queer ownvoices book in an author contest specifically for queer authors, because the contest is for books about “the struggle to be queer in the modern world”. So yes, there’s room to celebrate, for queer joy and plenty to be PROUD of.

But its the fight that sticks with me in 2023. This map of countries where its illegal to be queer won’t surprise experienced travellers like myself. But even to a casual observer, people referring to all LGBTQIA+ people as groomers (see Twitter) and claiming all of us are pedeophiles (see #NotADragQueen for convicted, actual child sex offenders) looks to me like people getting their ducks in a row before they shoot them. What is a Woman was described in this partly theatrical, but also thoroughly researched documentary as a rallying cry to incite hatred of and violence towards trans people. Having watched her full analysis of the book, I agree with Jessie Earl’s interpretation of it.

Yet so many bigoted morons on Twitter are tweeting ‘what rights are trans people being denied?’ Meanwhile a certain rich white woman would like everyone to believe cis women are victimised by the existence of trans women. And so many misogynists are happy to ‘defend’ TERFs against the existence of trans women (including literal, self identified fascists in my own city).

Pride to me?

In his monologue in June 2022, First Australian Mene Wyatt said “silence is violence.” A blog about Melbourne’s fascists expressed the view that most people, whom it called ‘normies’ truly oppose the ‘evil transes’. If fascists like that don’t hear people articulating that we actually don’t think trans people should be eradicated (yes, the Melbourne fascist banner called for exactly that), than Mene Wyatt is right. We’ll have haters committing violence in the name of ‘normal people’/ the bulk of the human population against LGBTQIA+ people —trans people first.

So to me, Pride is my chance to say: don’t let fascists presume they speak for you. Tell people where you stand. So no one can falsely claim to speak for you. Don’t be silent and let others believe they are committing violence in your name. (Fellow Aussies, we can use our voices to VOTE YES in the Voice Referendum, while we’re on the subject ?). Yes, things have come far for us queer folks and that’s great. But I want to see everything we’ve gained and so many have worked so hard for weather the current storm, futuresurvive and thrive.

Blue edged, pink, orange and yellow rainbow scroll with text: Get blogs in your inbox & updates from Elise every second month. Join my Fiction Frolics. Select this image to learn more.

Related Reading

Identifying as Nonbinary -my experience

Jessie Earl’s Debunking of What is A Woman, an excellent resource (long youtube video) for understanding conservative transphobia in the US.

I Think I’m Neurodiverse; ADHD? -Something I’m also proud about 🙂

[social_warfare]

LGBTQIA+ Life: Identifying as Nonbinary

Recognising your nonbinary gender in a binary, cis gender world is no picnic. You can’t name something the English language fails to hav relevant nouns and pronouns for, or that society fails to educate you about the existence of. So you blunder along, wondering why you don’t fit the man/ woman cookie cutters the world you are born and raised in tries to jam you into for the first thirty years of your life. It took me a few decades, but I figured things out in the end. This blog records my journey.

As a Kid, Gender didn’t matter as much

I’m a nineties kid, born and raised in Australia. Back then, their were boys and girls -that was it. In lower primary, I had two friendship groups. Girls with whom I played imaginary games. And tough boys, who, like me, were inclined to hit back when punched by random bullies in the yard. I got to wear pretty clothes and play with girly toys when I wanted. Alternately, I got to wear baggy t-shirts and shorts when I felt like it. And when I wanted to play with boys toys, my brothers were at my disposal. It was in later primary (around puberty) that I started to feel adrift.

I Don’t Quite Fit

Even before then, as young as eight, female friends had seemed closer to me than I was to them. And I didn’t quite like who I was around them. Something was off about me. Then, I changed schools and made new friends, but they were all girls. I didn’t feel like I connected to them as well as I had connected to boys. But boys saw me differently now. I was a ‘girl’ and someone they did or didn’t have a crush on. And that was it. And it was very disappointing. I had crushes as a teen, but as an asexual, friendship is infinitely more important to me than romantic relationships. I liked a boy at the time, but I didn’t actually want a boyfriend.

Early Teens

In hindsight, something that fuelled what was probably clinical levels of depression in my early teenage years (when I had a lot of non-gender related baggage to sort out), was my isolation. On one hand I was vastly more emotionally mature than most kids my age. On the other, I didn’t relate to a single kid at school when it came to gender identity.

Friendship groups were very much boys or girls in early high school. Boyfriends and dating were a thing. I had no prospect of male friendship. I related to girls even less than I had at primary school. And while I’m asexual, I could find certain boys aesthetically pleasing, or like their personality, but I always felt like they were more into me than I was into them. In hindsight, that’s because I’m also inclined towards a-romantic. So my gender neutral side was not destined to find a partner it related to, as I’ve never really wanted a romantic partner (beyond intellectual curiosity.)

Struggling to Relate

Late high school was bittersweet for me. I made some great friends, but the divide between single me and friends with boyfriends began. I knew some lovely girls in high school. But it wasn’t just the ones who had or sought boyfriends that I drifted away from. It was the more girly ones. They were lovely people, but I didn’t relate to them. They were too feminine. I did have some male friends around this time. There were a few boys who could see me not as a potential girlfriend or a ‘female’, just as a friend. I treasured them.

Boys brought out my gender neutral side. Girls generally brought out my feminine side. But when I’ve been surrounded by girls or women, with no break, I’ve felt kind of smothered. Its like those times use up all my femininity, and my gender neutrality was kind of shut in a room by itself. That was what felt off about having only female friends. That was why I couldn’t connect to girls and I haven’t been able to connect or relate to women the same way they usually connect and relate to me. Because I’m not a woman. The feminine is only half of who I am. When people only respond to my feminine side, displaying awareness of only its existence, it can feel like they only see me on the surface. Like they don’t truly know who I am.

In my Twenties, Nonbinary Clues

At Uni, there was more opportunity for female and male companionship. But I didn’t meet anyone who recognised me, or I them, as nonbinary. So who did I relate to more than 50% of the time? I often (pre-covid) travel by myself, and strike up conversations with retail assistants, people in hospitality and fellow tourists. Since joining Twitter, I’ve been very active in its WritingCommunity and created not one, but three writer Discord Servers. I’m a people loving person, whose always sensed an invisible barrier between myself and most people.

For my entire life, everyone I meet has assumed I am female. Girls and women have welcomed me as such. I have the lived experience of ‘girlhood’ and ‘womanhood’ so yes, I can relate to much of what women say. But in a conversation with multiple women, there always comes that point where the women are connecting more and more, and I’m feeling increasingly emotionally distant from them. I’m like a guest in their world. A welcome guest. On the surface, I fit in very well. But I don’t belong there.

That’s why male friendship and colleagues have always been so important to me. When men see me not as a ‘female’, nor as a potential date, just a person they can chat to and hang out with, my gender neutral side naturally engages with them. The other half of me gets to live. Its like oxygen after a bad head cold. Like pulling off too tight clothing that hinders your movements.

Selfie headshot of Elise wearing a long sleeve, blue patterned shirt and black frame topped glasses, and a blue-eyed, pink cheeked smile, Thin, pale trunked, sun dappled gum trees rising behind.
In the Aussie mountains, Victoria, 2023.

Gender Fluid Clues

And this is probably a good point for me to define the problem with ‘woman’ as an identity for me. Yes, I can relate to much of it. I can relate to the feminine as a feminine person. But at the end of the day, its a garment that’s too tight. It doesn’t allow me to be all I am. It masks my gender neutrality and my masculine side with make up and pretty clothes and all the cis female expectations society attaches to those.

When I told my mum I’m nonbinary, she tried to relate by saying how she enjoyed dressing up as a man at a dress up party once. When I wear a pretty dress and make up to dinner (very rarely), that’s almost the same to me as going to dinner dressed as a man. Why? Because it isn’t who I am. Yes, I do sometimes wear dresses. But I’ve donated the prettiest to charity. I like them, but I’d rather pin them to my wall and admire them. Or admire them on women. I don’t actually feel like wearing them much, because they’re not me.

I talk about ‘women’ -not me. I talk about ‘men’ -also not me. If you’ve noticed this, it shouldn’t surprise you that in my twenties I defined myself simply as, ‘I am not most people. I do not do what most people do. I cannot relate to either binary gender the way they relate to themselves, or each other.’

I know Who I Want to Be When I Grow Up!

Other kids looked to pop stars etc, and said, ‘I want to be like that when I grow up!’ I never felt that way. I saw only little bits of me in any one person, perhaps in part because they were all binary men and women. But in my early twenties, I saw much of myself in a fictional character. A sociable, people loving person. A traveler, passing through, helping out where they can: Dr Who. No, not Jodie Whitaker. David Tenant’s portrayal. And Matt Smith’s. I find Dr Who in the new seasons quite androgynous. Unbound by gender in character, behaviour, thinking and feeling. And that removes what would otherwise have been a barrier to other Dr Who traits I relate to.

Gender Fluid –Wardrobe Development

When I started teaching in 2011, I was drawn to women’s professional clothing. Its more stylish, interesting, arty or attractive. And I like elegance. So in summer, when I noticed very few smart shorts for women, I found myself in dresses five days a week. By Friday, I felt like the wind had gone out of my sails. I wasn’t quite myself. I also noticed that when I skipped my usual evening run, I felt sad. In hindsight, it wasn’t exercise I missed most. It was doing what has traditionally been a masculine activity, in gender neutral clothes, which gave my gender neutral side room to breathe.

From then onwards, I made a point of wearing gender neutral casual clothes at home, and for exercise. I reserved feminine clothing as much as practical for work. Dressing half the time in a feminine way and half the time gender neutral worked for me. That’s a nice clear point to establish that I’m not only nonbinary, I’m gender fluid. My mood, my responses, which other gender I relate to best changes not just every day, but can change throughout the day as well.

In recent years, I’ve removed the prettiest clothing in my wardrobe. I’m happiest in clothing I can be comfortable in whether I’m in a feminine or a more gender neutral mood, as that’s likely to change after I get dressed for the day. And while I can be happy in androgynous clothing for five days in a row, I’ll often wear dresses for a couple of days after that. Its all about balancing gender neutral and feminine for me.

Still Not Relating

A teacher in my twenties, its after 2011 and I still haven’t claimed ‘gender fluid’ or ‘nonbinary’ as my identity. One of many schools I’ve worked at liked Friday night drinks. It was usually a few women and a few men. Every time, we’d start off sitting and talking together. Then came that inevitable point when the women gravitated towards and chatted with one another and the men did the same. I always, usually quite literally, found myself sitting in the middle, drawn to neither. I’d sit looking from one to the other, and have to choose which to make an effort to join in with. Sometimes I’d just listen and sip my drink for twenty minutes, before saying a word. That’s unlike me. Here was more proof that I simply did not relate, connect or gravitate to a binary gender the way either gravitates towards itself.

Appropriate Labels

So when did I FINALLY find the words to name the identity I’d pretty much figured out by now? It was after Miley Cyrus identified as ‘girl’ and ‘boy.’ After a celebrity or two announced that they would like to be referred to by the personal pronoun ‘they’. In a society seeing and expecting nothing but binary male or female, words were finally finding me.

That wasn’t the end. By now, I was in my thirties. Still teaching. I’d had a lifetime of not relating to either binary gender the way they related to each other. A lifetime of being a stranger, just passing through, who meets, likes and helps people, then moves on, without fully connecting. I defined myself now as simply ‘other’. As ‘labels, boxes, societal conventions, blah, blah, blah don’t apply to me’.

In my teens, I was often labelled an ‘airhead’ because being a pretty, female-presenting, thin person was perceived as scientific proof of lack of brain cells (or so thought many a moron). I’d been labelled a ‘slut’ in my teens at times too (oh yes, despite zero dating, kissing or even hand holding and oh yeah, being asexual!) I was used to not being seen, being mislabelled (and in my teenage years, to thinking most people were idiots because they consistently failed to notice SO MANY things that were bloody obvious to me).

Gender Identity Became A Thing

Now, I was 33 and had joined Twitter’s WritingCommunity. By this time, ‘sex’ was no longer a synonymn for ‘gender’. People didn’t speak of ‘gender reassignment surgery’, like they had in the nineties. Now, I’d come more often across the word ‘trans’. I was introduced to the idea that gender identity, who a person is in their mind, their heart, their soul can differ from biological sex. I started hearing that trans men are men, and trans women are women. For the first time in my life, a fact that was self evident to me was finally visible to other people: that biological sex does not determine a person’s gender.

Twitter was the first time in my life that I was given the choice of stating my personal pronouns. Not having them dictated to me by a cis, binary gender society. Of actually telling people who I was, myself. But what the fuck words did I use?

Label & Personal Pronoun Aversion

Then there was the other problem. I’d privately concluded that when it comes to my gender, people have no fucking clue what I am. There was no point trying to tell them something they knew nothing about, using words that didn’t exist. I’d forgiven them for their ignorance and was moving on with my life.

Now the words did exist. But for thirty three years I’d never applied them to me. Since the age of fifteen, I’d had an aversion to boxes, labels or categories of any sort. After all that time resisting boxes, did I now elect to put myself into one? And having called myself simply ‘nonconformist’ in my teens, ‘other’ in my twenties and simply ‘me’ by my thirties, did I now want to give my gender a name that was foreign to me? I’d heard that ‘they’ singular was becoming a thing, but it too had had nothing to do with me for my entire life.

I totally accepted the idea of putting personal pronouns in Twitter bios. It challenged the assumption that biological sex is the sole determinant of gender. It encouraged cis people looking at a profile pic, going ‘biological male = man’, to stop, and recognise that actually, she is a trans woman. I also liked the idea of normalising personal pronouns in bios, so the onus of identifying gender isn’t just on trans people, its on everyone. Why am I not mentioning nonbinary folks here? Because the conversation I saw at that time didn’t yet include nonbinary people.

Overcoming my Label Aversion

My problem? Other people called me she/ her/ woman all my life. They were the only personal pronouns. Suddenly I had the choice to use ‘they’. I didn’t, at first. I used she/her to signal my Twitter feed was a trans friendly space. But it felt wrong. So I pulled back to ‘she’. On its own, ‘she’ wasn’t enough. ‘They’ was still alien, so for a year, I went to no pronouns. (If you’re in this boat, ‘all pronouns welcome’ or ‘pronouns any’ is a good way to indicate your account is trans friendly. I only heard of it later).

By now, its was 2020. Months of lockdown awaited me, as did unemployment when I spent lockdown in Australia and couldn’t return to teaching in New Zealand. I had time to think. To reflect. And FINALLY, I met and interacted with nobinary people on Twitter. It was a short leap to realise I’d found my people. To re-writing my author bio on this site using they/ them/ their pronouns, to try it on.

For a few weeks, I felt painfully aware of personal pronouns in general. Every pronoun in my author bio seemed to be shouting. But I kept switching my pronouns, on Discord, then Twitter. Because it felt right. It fit. And in telling people my personal pronouns aren’t just ‘she/her’, they’re ‘they/ them and their’, I felt like I was giving myself room to breath. To speak, act, dress and relate to others in a gender neutral way when I was in a gender neutral mood. To be masculine on occasion and to act feminine when I felt that. With a balance of feminine and gender neutral, in clothing, speech, actions and how I relate to other people, throughout my day and week, I’m comfortable. Happiest. Myself.

Blue edged, pink, orange and yellow rainbow scroll with text: Get blogs in your inbox & updates from Elise every second month. Join my Fiction Frolics. Select this image to learn more.
Total Page Visits: 4615

Related Reading

What Does Pride Mean To You? by me.

I Just Came Out as Nonbinary, Here’s What That Means, by Arlo, at Minus18.

Gender Definitions and Personal Pronoun info & advice, by NPR.

On perceiving nonbinary: Some Thoughts on Being Nonbinary by Luke Roelofs.

I Think I’m Neurodiverse. ADHD? by me.

[social_warfare]

© 2026 Elise Carlson

Theme by Anders NorenUp ↑